IIM B UG (B.Sc-Hons.) - 2026 Actual Exam · Logical Reasoning · Question 7
IIM B UG (B.Sc-Hons.) - 2026 Actual Exam question on Critical Reasoning — Simpson’s Paradox, with the answer and a step-by-step solution.
A review report concludes that Hospital B performed better than Hospital A in treating patients with COVID-19 in terms of the survival rates computed from the data presented in the table below.
Hospital | COVID-19 Case type | Patients | Survived |
|---|---|---|---|
A | Mild | 100 | 99 |
A | Severe | 900 | 720 |
B | Mild | 900 | 892 |
B | Severe | 100 | 48 |
Which of the following statements provides the strongest evidence against the conclusion of the report?
- AThe overall survival rate was higher in Hospital A as compared to Hospital B.
- BHospital A treated higher percentage of Severe patients as compared to Hospital B.
- CThe survival rate among Mild cases was higher in Hospital B as compared to Hospital A.
- DHospital A did not treat more patients than Hospital B.
Answer & solution
Answer: Option B
Compute the rates:
Mild | Severe | Overall | |
|---|---|---|---|
Hospital A | 99/100=99.0\% | 720/900=80.0\% | 819/1000=81.9\% |
Hospital B | 892/900=99.1\% | 48/100=48.0\% | 940/1000=94.0\% |
B’s overall rate (94%) is higher than A’s (81.9%) — that is the report’s basis. Yet within the severe group A is far better (80% vs 48%), and for mild cases the two are about equal. This is Simpson’s paradox: the overall figures are driven by the case mix — Hospital A got 90% severe patients, Hospital B only 10% — not by quality of treatment.
Option 2 exposes exactly this confounder, so overall comparison is unfair → strongest evidence against the report.
Option 1 is factually wrong (A’s overall rate is lower).
Option 3 is true but supports B (the report), if anything.
Option 4 is irrelevant: both treated 1000 patients.
Answer: Option 2.
Take this paper as a timed test
Real exam timing, instant score, rank and topic-wise analysis.