IIM B UG (B.Sc-Hons.) - 2026 Actual Exam · Logical Reasoning · Question 3
IIM B UG (B.Sc-Hons.) - 2026 Actual Exam question on Critical Reasoning — Weaken, with the answer and a step-by-step solution.
A state ranks its 600 schools based on the average score of students in the board examination. The teachers from the bottom 50 schools based on last year’s rank underwent an intensive teacher-training program. This year, average score of students from those 50 schools improved by 9% on average, while those from the other 550 improved by 2% on average. Officials concluded that the training program is successful.
Which one of the following, if true, most weakens that conclusion?
- AThe list of 50 schools which appear in the bottom of ranking fluctuates widely from year to year.
- BSome students change their schools in between years.
- CThe salary of teachers was increased across the state this year after a gap of 10 years.
- DTeachers from the other 550 schools received no training of any kind.
Answer & solution
Answer: Option A
Argument. Conclusion: the training programme works. Evidence: the schools that were at the bottom last year improved more (9%) than the rest (2%).
Hidden assumption: the improvement was caused by the training, rather than by something else.
Option 1 (correct). If the identity of the bottom 50 keeps changing widely from year to year, then a school that happened to have a bad year will usually score better the next year simply because bad years don’t repeat — regression to the mean. The 9% jump may then be nothing more than statistical rebound, which directly undermines the causal claim.
Option 2. Some students switching schools affects all schools in a small, undirected way — it doesn’t explain why the bottom group alone improved.
Option 3. A statewide pay rise would affect all 600 schools alike; it can’t explain the difference (9% vs 2%) between the groups, and is even somewhat consistent with the 2% gain in the others.
Option 4. This actually strengthens the conclusion: the comparison group was untrained, so the difference is more plausibly attributable to training.
Answer: Option 1.
Take this paper as a timed test
Real exam timing, instant score, rank and topic-wise analysis.