IIM B UG (B.Sc-Hons.) - 2026 Actual Exam · Logical Reasoning · Question 1
IIM B UG (B.Sc-Hons.) - 2026 Actual Exam question on Deductive Logic, with the answer and a step-by-step solution.
A club applies the following five rules to its members.
Every member who coaches also umpires.
Every member on the finance panel pays a levy.
No umpire is on the finance panel.
No member who pays a levy umpires.
No member on the finance panel coaches.
Which one of the following rules is/are redundant given the other rules?
Rule 3
Rule 5
- ABoth (I) and (II)
- BOnly (II)
- CNeither (I) nor (II)
- DOnly (I)
Answer & solution
Answer: Option A
A rule is redundant if it follows logically from the remaining four.
Rule 3 (“no umpire is on the finance panel”): from Rule 2, a finance-panel member pays a levy; from Rule 4, a levy payer does not umpire. Chain: finance panel \Rightarrow pays levy \Rightarrow not an umpire. So no one on the finance panel is an umpire — this is Rule 3. Redundant.
Rule 5 (“no finance-panel member coaches”): suppose a finance-panel member coached. By Rule 1 they would also umpire. But by Rules 2 and 4 (or by Rule 3) a finance-panel member does not umpire — a contradiction. So no finance-panel member coaches. Redundant.
Rules 1, 2 and 4 alone already imply both Rule 3 and Rule 5, so each of the two is redundant given the others.
Answer: Option 1 (Both (I) and (II)).
Take this paper as a timed test
Real exam timing, instant score, rank and topic-wise analysis.