CUET (UG) 2025 English · 21 May (Shift 1) · VARC · Question 4

CUET (UG) 2025 English · 21 May (Shift 1) previous year question on RC Inference Questions, with the answer and a step-by-step solution.

RC Inference QuestionsReading Comprehension - Question TypesMultiple choiceMedium

RC passage 1: CUET 2025 — 21 May 2025, Shift 1 — Passage 1 — The claim that risks nothing — this question belongs to a set. Read the full set with all 5 questions →

Read the passage carefully and answer the questions that follow.

A theory that can explain any outcome explains none. The remark sounds paradoxical and is not. To say something informative about the world is to rule certain things out; a claim compatible with every observation has ruled nothing out and therefore told us nothing about which world we are in.

This gives a usable test. Ask of any theory what it forbids. A good one answers promptly and precisely: it says that a body will fall at such a rate, that an eclipse will occur at such a minute, and if the body falls otherwise or the sky stays bright, the theory is in trouble. A weak one answers vaguely or not at all, and its defenders treat its capacity to accommodate every result as its great strength, which is exactly backwards.

The test is less tidy in practice than in statement. A failed prediction can always be absorbed by adjusting some assumption elsewhere, and doing so is not automatically dishonest; serious science has often been rescued by exactly that move, and the rescue has sometimes been vindicated. What distinguishes the respectable case from the evasive one is whether the adjustment itself forbids something new. An adjustment made solely to explain away the failure, forbidding nothing further, has bought survival at the cost of content.

So the question to put to a theory is not whether it has ever been wrong but whether it is the kind of thing that could be. A discipline whose claims have never once been exposed to a result that might have embarrassed them is not thereby more secure. It is merely untested, and should not be mistaken for a discipline whose claims have been exposed repeatedly and survived.

The passage implies that a discipline none of whose claims has ever been embarrassed by a result is
  1. A
    especially well confirmed.
  2. B
    untested rather than secure.
  3. C
    certainly mistaken in its conclusions.
  4. D
    too young to be judged fairly.
Pick an option, then check.
Answer & solution

Answer: Option B

The last paragraph says such a discipline is not thereby more secure but merely untested, and warns against confusing it with one that has been exposed and survived. Option 3 goes further than the passage, which charges emptiness rather than error.

More RC Inference Questions questions

All RC Inference Questions PYQs →

Take this paper as a timed test
Real exam timing, instant score, rank and topic-wise analysis.

Practice timed →