CAT 2024 Slot 1 · VARC · RC passage 3: Crafts, Efficiency and Creativity

The full passage and all 4 questions (Q17–Q20) from CAT 2024 Slot 1, with answers and solutions.

The passage below is accompanied by four questions. Based on the passage, choose the best answer for each question.

. . . [T]he idea of craftsmanship is not simply nostalgic. . . . Crafts require distinct skills, an all-round approach to work that involves the whole product, rather than individual parts, and an attitude that necessitates devotion to the job and a focus on the communal interest. The concept of craft emphasises the human touch and individual judgment.

Essentially, the crafts concept seems to run against the preponderant ethos of management studies which, as the academics note, have long prioritised efficiency and consistency. . . . Craft skills were portrayed as being primitive and traditionalist.

The contrast between artisanship and efficiency first came to the fore in the 19th century when British manufacturers suddenly faced competition from across the Atlantic as firms developed the "American system" using standardised parts. . . the worldwide success of the Singer sewing machine showed the potential of a mass-produced device. This process created its own reaction, first in the form of the Arts and Crafts movement of the late 19th century, and then again in the "small is beautiful" movement of the 1970s. A third crafts movement is emerging as people become aware of the environmental impact of conventional industry.

There are two potential markets for those who practise crafts. The first stems from the existence of consumers who are willing to pay a premium price for goods that are deemed to be of extra quality. . . . The second market lies in those consumers who wish to use their purchases to support local workers, or to reduce their environmental impact by taking goods to craftspeople to be mended, or recycled.

For workers, the appeal of craftsmanship is that it allows them the autonomy to make creative choices, and thus makes a job far more satisfying. In that sense, it could offer hope for the overall labour market. Let the machines automate dull and repetitive tasks and let workers focus purely on their skills, judgment and imagination. As a current example, the academics cite the "agile" manifesto in the software sector, an industry at the heart of technological change. The pioneers behind the original agile manifesto promised to prioritise "individuals and interactions over processes and tools". By bringing together experts from different teams, agile working is designed to improve creativity.

But the broader question is whether crafts can create a lot more jobs than they do today. Demand for crafted products may rise but will it be easy to retrain workers in sectors that might get automated (such as truck drivers) to take advantage? In a world where products and services often have to pass through regulatory hoops, large companies will usually have the advantage.

History also suggests that the link between crafts and creativity is not automatic. Medieval craft guilds were monopolies which resisted new entrants. They were also highly hierarchical with young men required to spend long periods as apprentices and journeymen before they could set up on their own; by that time the innovative spirit may have been knocked out of them. Craft workers can thrive in the modern era, but only if they don't get too organised.

Question 17 · RC Inference Questions

We can infer from the passage that medieval crafts guilds resembled mass production in that both
  1. A
    discouraged innovation by restricting entry through strict rules.
  2. B
    did not always employ egalitarian production processes.
  3. C
    did not necessarily promote creativity.
  4. D
    focused excessively on product quality.
Pick an option, then check.
Answer & solution

Answer: Option C

The answer must be true of both systems. Mass production – the 'American system' of standardised parts and the Singer sewing machine – belongs to an ethos that 'prioritised efficiency and consistency', under which craft skills were seen as 'primitive and traditionalist'; creativity is not what it is built to produce. The guilds: 'the link between crafts and creativity is not automatic. Medieval craft guilds were monopolies which resisted new entrants... by that time the innovative spirit may have been knocked out of them.' Neither system necessarily promoted creativity.

Option 3 is the shared trait.

Option 1 fits the guilds, which 'resisted new entrants', but nothing suggests mass production restricted entry.

Option 2 fits the guilds' hierarchy, but the passage says nothing about how egalitarian mass production was.

Option 4 fails on both counts: mass production is linked to efficiency and consistency, and it is craftsmanship that the passage links to quality goods.

Shortcut: in a 'both X and Y' question, test each option against the less-discussed side first – here mass production. Most distractors are true of only the side the passage dwells on.

Hence, the answer is option 3.

Question 18 · RC Inference Questions

Which one of the following statements is NOT inconsistent with the views stated in the passage?
  1. A
    We need to support the crafts; only then can we retain the creativity intrinsic to their production.
  2. B
    The Arts and Crafts movement was initially inspired by the "American system" of production.
  3. C
    Creativity in the crafts could be stifled if the market for artisan goods becomes too organised.
  4. D
    The agile movement in software is a throwback to the tenets of the medieval crafts guilds.
Pick an option, then check.
Answer & solution

Answer: Option C

'NOT inconsistent with' means consistent with, so find the statement the passage would accept. The last sentence gives it: 'Craft workers can thrive in the modern era, but only if they don't get too organised.' The discussion of guilds explains why – monopoly, resistance to newcomers and long hierarchical apprenticeships knocked the innovative spirit out of workers.

Option 3 restates that warning.

Option 1 says creativity is 'intrinsic' to craft production, which the passage denies: 'the link between crafts and creativity is not automatic'.

Option 2 reverses history. The Arts and Crafts movement arose as a reaction against the American system, not as something inspired by it.

Option 4 misreads the agile example, which is offered as a hopeful modern case of autonomy and creativity – the opposite of the rigid, hierarchical guild.

Shortcut: convert the double negative first ('NOT inconsistent' = consistent), then check the passage's closing sentence – authors usually put their own view there.

Hence, the answer is option 3.

Question 19 · RC Detail and Fact Based Questions

The author questions the ability of crafts to create substantial employment opportunities presently because
  1. A
    the low scale of crafts production will not be able to absorb the mass of redundant labour.
  2. B
    regulatory requirements could make it difficult for small crafts outfits to compete.
  3. C
    workers made redundant by automation are unlikely to opt for crafts-related work.
  4. D
    crafts guilds tend to resist new entrants and are unlikely to accept large numbers of trainees.
Pick an option, then check.
Answer & solution

Answer: Option B

The relevant paragraph opens with the question – 'whether crafts can create a lot more jobs than they do today' – and ends with the author's answer: 'In a world where products and services often have to pass through regulatory hoops, large companies will usually have the advantage.' If large companies are better at clearing regulatory hurdles, small craft outfits are at a disadvantage, and the job-creating potential of crafts is limited.

Option 2 states this reasoning.

Option 3 is the strongest distractor, since the paragraph asks whether it will be 'easy to retrain workers' such as truck drivers. But that is about whether retraining is feasible, not about whether workers would choose crafts work.

Option 1 invents an argument about scale that does not appear.

Option 4 moves the medieval guilds, discussed later as evidence about creativity, into a present-day argument about jobs.

Shortcut: when a paragraph poses a question and then gives a 'In a world where...' sentence, that sentence is the author's answer. Match the option to it.

Hence, the answer is option 2.

Question 20 · RC Detail and Fact Based Questions

The most recent revival in interest in the crafts is a result of the emergence of all of the following EXCEPT:
  1. A
    concerns about the environmental impact of mass production.
  2. B
    a niche market for discerning buyers of quality products.
  3. C
    support for individual creations as opposed to mass-produced objects.
  4. D
    a greater interest in buying locally produced goods.
Pick an option, then check.
Answer & solution

Answer: Option C

Three options can each be traced to a sentence. Option 1: 'A third crafts movement is emerging as people become aware of the environmental impact of conventional industry.' Option 2: the first market 'stems from the existence of consumers who are willing to pay a premium price for goods that are deemed to be of extra quality'. Option 4: the second market lies in consumers who 'wish to use their purchases to support local workers'.

Option 3 cannot be traced. The passage does say 'the concept of craft emphasises the human touch and individual judgment', but that is a definition of craft in the opening paragraph, not a force behind the recent revival. Nowhere does the passage say buyers are turning to crafts out of a preference for individual creations over mass-produced goods.

Shortcut: in an EXCEPT question, underline the stated causes of the event asked about. An option that echoes a general description from elsewhere in the passage, rather than a stated cause, is usually the exception.

Hence, the answer is option 3.

Take this paper as a timed test
Real exam timing, instant score, rank and topic-wise analysis.

Practice timed →